Madison East SFR | Fix & Flip / BRRRR | ARV ~$405K | Buy $295,000 | Big Spread

5018 Trafalger Pl

Madison, WI 53714

Listed: October 10, 2025

View Location on Google Maps

View Photos: Click Here

Price : $295,000

ARV: $405,000

Repairs: $10,000- $20,000

Type: Single Family Residential

Year Built: 1979

Bedrooms: 3

Bathrooms: 2 (Full)

Call or Text Will to make an offer:

(727) 977-5543

Summary

Madison East SFR | Fix & Flip / BRRRR | ARV ~$405K | Buy $295,000 | Big Spread

Price : $295,000

📍 City: Madison, WI

🌆 County: Dane

🏡 Property Type: Single Family Residential

Property Details:

Property Overview:

-Type: Single-Family Residence (SFR)

-Beds/Baths: 3/2 

-Living Area: 1640 Sq Ft. 

-Lot Size: 9072 Sq Ft. 

-Year Built: 1979 

-Parking: Attached Garage 

-Utilities: City Water & Sewer 

Property Highlights:

- Quiet residential pocket on Madison’s East Side—close to parks, schools, retail, and dining.

- Fast access to US-151, Hwy-30, and I-39/90; ~10–15 minutes to Downtown Madison and UW-Madison.

- Ideal Fix & Flip or BRRRR: strong owner-occupant demand + tight inventory in 53714.

- Functional layout with value-add potential in kitchen/bath and basement finish.

- Solid rental comps nearby support stable cash flow after rehab.

Repairs Needed:

- Interior: Full cosmetic refresh (paint, LVP/carpet, trim), kitchen modernization (cabs, counters, appliances), bathroom updates (tile, vanity, tub/shower).

- Mechanical: Inspect/upgrade HVAC/water heater as needed; verify electrical panel and GFCIs; plumbing fixtures/lines as needed.

- Exterior: Curb appeal (landscaping, exterior paint/siding touch-ups), evaluate roof age/condition, windows/doors weather-seal.

- Basement/Structure: Inspect for moisture and address grading/drainage if needed; optional rec-room finish for ARV lift.

- Safety/Code: Smoke/CO detectors, handrails, egress compliance as applicable.

After-Repair Value (ARV) – Madison 53714 (East Side):

- Estimated ARV Range: $405,000 assuming 3BR/1–2BA, modernized kitchen/bath, refreshed exterior, and finished cosmetics typical for the area.

- Basis: Recent renovated SFR sales within ~0.25–1.0 mi, similar vintage and footprint (see COMPS tab for addresses, bed/bath, GLA, DOM, and sold dates).

Comps:

- 4530 Stein Avenue, Madison, WI 53714 - This home last sold for $400,000 in May 2025.

- 4614 Boynton Place, Madison, WI 53714 - This home last sold for $425,000 in September 2025.

- 9 Gem COURT, Madison, WI 53714  - This home last sold for $385,000 in December 2024.

- 5113 Milwaukee Street, Madison, WI 53714 - This home last sold for $402,500 in July 2025.

- 5118 HACKNEY Way, Madison, WI 53714 - This home last sold for $412,000 in April 2025.

Exit Scenarios:

- Potential Rent Returns

- Typical East-Side renovated 3BR rents are competitive; pro-forma supports positive cash flow after CapEx reserve.

- Vacancy is historically low; strong tenant demand from proximity to employment centers and UW corridor.

Remember: You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take—submit that offer and lock this one up before the next investor does!

Call now to make an offer!

Will Humphrey

(727) 977 5543

[email protected]

We specialize in sourcing deeply discounted real estate deals for investors. Whether you’re looking for your next flip, rental, or long-term hold, we provide a steady stream of off-market properties at prices that make sense.

Contact Us

(727) 855-8811

7901 4th St N STE 300

St. Petersburg, FL 33702

©2025 Copyright Wise Investments | All Rights Reserved

Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy